Shop Now King's Hawaiian Original BBQ Sauce, $6, Though a tiny bit on the sweet side, this sauce was pretty well balanced with notes of honey and apples and horseradish. stated one judge. Splendid Table Co-op members will get exclusive content each month and have special opportunities for connecting with The Splendid Table team. But it gives it a wild color; it turns bright orange. If you're looking for a sauce with tropical vibes, look no further. A barbecue sauce for fans of sweet stuff. This … To make things more complicated, there are more types to choose from out there than Lady Gaga has outfits, including regional variations like thin, tangy North Carolina–style and flavors like mesquite, honey, and sweet 'n' spicy, to name a few. Jardine's 5-Star, Olde Cape Cod Sweet & Bold, Duke's New York Roadhouse, Butternut Mountain Farm, Heffys Original, Hunt's Original, Stubb's Original, Emeril's Bam! I own three barbecue restaurants all over the country.

It's a community of like-minded individuals who love good food, good conversation and kitchen companionship. JB: This is not a case of necessarily a “bad sauce,” it’s just a different sauce. There are many regional takes on barbecue in the United States, each with its own idea of the perfect sauce to complement barbecued meats.

Chef Hymie Grande's Barbecue Glaze may be free of high-fructose corn syrup and processed sugar (they market themselves as meeting the standards of the American Diabetes Association), but it was far too bland for our tastes. Best Barbecue Sauce Overall. Bull’s-Eye Original BBQ Sauce $2.59 for 18 oz ($0.14 per oz) This “all-purpose” product won over tasters with its “balanced sweetness,” “tomatoey” flavor, “subtle smoke,” and “nice tang,” all “without any of the flavors overwhelming each other.” This “straightforward” barbecue sauce was “immediately pleasing to the palate” and “not as gloppy” as some others. JB: This last idea is going to rock your world because it’s so out there – a barbecue vinaigrette. We always do stuff straight from the bottle. Trust this bottle with all your barbecuing needs. BUY NOW King's Hawaiian Smoked Bacon BBQ Sauce, $5.

Perfect for chicken or pork. But when you think about what’s on the supermarket shelves across the country, the sweet, tomato sauce that’s thick and clingy, like they make in Kansas City, is what most Americans think of. For those who favor Carolina-style barbecue, this vinegary sauce is the holy grail. The Splendid Table frequently visits with the test cooks at America’s Test Kitchen to discuss a wide range of topics including recipes, ingredients, techniques and kitchen equipment. Winner: Sweet Baby Ray's Original Award Winning Barbecue Sauce($7.00 for 18-ounce bottle), Pros: The majority of the judges awarded this sauce four forks. After we do a tasting, we always monitor to see if the product changes. It's got everything you want in a barbecue sauce: perfectly balanced flavor, nice texture, and a smokiness that won't overpower your food. Sweet Baby Ray’s Barbecue Sauce $2.69 for 18 oz ($0.15 per oz) This pleasantly “sugary” and “robust” product’s “instant hit of flavor” and “tangy bite” added up to “pretty perfect” flavor for some tasters, even though it seemed “supersweet” to others. Barbecue season approaches, and with so many barbecue sauces on the market, it can feel impossible to choose. We also do cooking applications and use them in pulled pork. You still add mayonnaise, but you cut it about 50/50 with barbecue sauce. JB: Sweetness, but not too much. Original, Jack Daniel's Original No. Take One Can. You can talk to people in North Carolina who make very vinegary sauces or in Texas, where they have very particular opinions on what barbecue sauce should be. Try making the America’s Test Kitchen recipe for Kansas City BBQ Sauce. The “deep and smoky” sauce was “delicious,” “pure barbecue flavor” to some, but others found it “artificial” and thought this “meaty and savory” sauce “could use a pinch more sweetness.”. So we decided to taste the offerings and choose our favorites. JB: That’s correct. SS:  You did a tasting – actually it was the second time around for you because your past champion changed its sweetener. It has that sweet yet tangy taste that cannot be duplicated by any other sauce. It was unpleasantly grainy, and more like what one would imagine if V8 were to make a BBQ sauce. A few tasters took issue with the sauce’s “unassuming” taste, saying the flavor was “too weak” and “needed a little more of a kick.”, Kraft Original Barbecue Sauce & Dip $1.99 for 18 oz ($0.11 per oz) This “candy-like” sauce’s “unique flavor” reminded tasters of “pumpkin-spiced barbecue” and “roasted fruit.” Even though this “very sweet” product was overwhelming for some and the “almost plummy” flavor “may not be mainstream enough,” the sauce was lauded for its “nice heat” and “hint of smoke.”, Jack Daniel’s Original No. Stubb’s Original Legendary Bar-B-Q Sauce $4.49 for 18 oz ($0.25 per oz) Tasters likened this Texas-style (rather than Kansas City-style) product to “spicy, watery ketchup” that “was not sweet at all.” The “tart” and “sour” flavor reminded one taster of “old tomato puree,” while others took issue with the “metallic aftertaste” and “very thin” texture. Seniors On Medicare Are Getting a Big Pay Day in 2020, Expert: “This credit card is so good I signed up personally”. This product’s “ketchupy” texture made it an “excellent barbecue sauce for dipping” while the “good spiciness” lent a “touch of heat.”, KC Masterpiece Original Barbecue Sauce $1.69 for 18 oz ($0.09 per oz) Most tasters enjoyed this product’s “pleasantly smoky” and “supersweet” flavor; its “good cling” and “thick” texture further won over tasters. They should go hand in hand like a hot dog and bun. "That is one good- looking sauce!

The molasses in this one provides a sweetness and tang that many of the other contenders lacked. 3) Bulls-Eye Original BBQ Sauce Sweet, acidic, salty, smoky, this sauce has it all. Most fell into the smoky-sweet category that's come to be thought of as "classic" barbecue sauce. More than 50% of our tasters voted for this classic.